Best Shingles for Roof Replacement2025 Top-Rated Options
Compare the top-performing shingles from GAF, CertainTeed, and Owens Corning. Find the perfect balance of performance, aesthetics, and value for your home.
2025 Quick Picks
Best combination of performance, warranty, and value
Class 4 impact + 130 MPH wind rating
Luxury slate appearance with lifetime warranty
Understanding Shingle Categories
Modern asphalt shingles come in three main categories, each offering different benefits.
3-Tab Shingles
Entry-level option
✓ Most affordable option
✓ Easy to repair
✗ Shorter lifespan
✗ Limited wind resistance
Architectural Shingles
Best value for most homes
✓ Excellent wind resistance
✓ Enhanced curb appeal
✓ Better warranties
✓ Algae resistance available
Designer Shingles
Luxury appearance & performance
✓ Authentic slate/shake look
✓ Longest lifespan
✓ Lifetime warranties
⚠ Higher cost
Top-Rated Shingles for 2025
GAFAmerica's #1 Shingle Manufacturer
Timberline HDZ
Architectural
The most popular shingle in North America. LayerLock technology provides exceptional wind performance.
- ✓ 130 MPH wind warranty (with LayerLock)
- ✓ StainGuard Plus algae protection
- ✓ Lifetime limited warranty
- ✓ 25-year Golden Pledge available
Grand Canyon
Designer/Luxury
Authentic wood shake appearance with ultra-dimensional profile and random-cut appearance.
- ✓ 130 MPH wind warranty
- ✓ StainGuard Plus algae protection
- ✓ Lifetime limited warranty
- ✓ Class A fire rating
CertainTeedQuality Since 1904
Landmark
Architectural
Multi-layered design with Max Def color technology for rich, vibrant color options.
- ✓ 110 MPH wind resistance
- ✓ StreakFighter algae protection
- ✓ Lifetime limited warranty
- ✓ Class A fire rating
Grand Manor
Designer/Luxury
The look of fine natural slate with dimensional depth and color variation.
- ✓ 110 MPH wind resistance
- ✓ Lifetime warranty
- ✓ Impact resistant options
- ✓ Premium color palette
Owens CorningPink Panther Innovation
Duration
Architectural
SureNail Technology provides exceptional grip and wind resistance in all weather conditions.
- ✓ 130 MPH wind warranty
- ✓ StreakGuard algae protection
- ✓ Lifetime limited warranty
- ✓ TruDefinition color technology
Duration STORM
Impact Resistant
Class 4 impact rating meets 130 MPH wind resistance for ultimate storm protection.
- ✓ Class 4 impact rating (UL 2218)
- ✓ 130 MPH wind warranty
- ✓ May qualify for insurance discount
- ✓ Ideal for hail-prone areas
2025 Shingle Innovations
Modern shingles offer technology unavailable just 5 years ago.
Enhanced Wind Ratings
Up to 150 MPH wind resistance with improved adhesive strips and nail zones.
Impact Resistance
Class 4 rated shingles withstand 2-inch hailstones without damage.
Algae Resistance
Copper-infused granules prevent black streaks for 25+ years.
Cool Roof Technology
Reflective granules reduce attic temperatures by up to 20°F.
Best Shingles for Coastal South Carolina
For Myrtle Beach and the Grand Strand, we recommend architectural shingles with these features:
Must-Have Features:
- ✓ 130+ MPH wind rating
- ✓ Algae-resistant granules
- ✓ Enhanced nailing zones
- ✓ 30+ year warranty
Our Top Picks:
- 1. GAF Timberline HDZ
- 2. Owens Corning Duration STORM
- 3. CertainTeed Landmark Pro
Need Help Choosing the Right Shingle?
Our GAF Master Elite certified team can recommend the perfect shingle for your home, budget, and climate needs.